I thought this was really beautiful. But I'd remove some of this stanza. It takes away from your poem imo.

My dad came in my dream He said
''Don't worry...WAIT AND SEE...ENJOY LIFE...
ONE DAY IT WILL RAIN GOLD FOR THEE..
See my picture this ... <---- this line I'd turn my into me
but you can't download it ..
be brave as always''

I'd remove that whole first line. It detracts from the flow of the poem. It's like an intermission thrust into the middle of the flow for me. Oh I'd also remove the captials it's like Dads yelling in your dream.

Other than those small things I think it's an excellent poem.

Love and hugs Sis x

As an experiment, we are using a leading large language model (in other words, AI) to provide critiques of poems that were posted recently. Please let us know what you think.

Computer critique:

"My Dad Loved Me" is a free verse poem that explores the complexities of the relationship between the speaker and their father, as well as the impact of family dynamics on this relationship. The poem is written in a conversational tone, creating an intimate atmosphere that allows the reader to connect with the speaker's emotions and experiences.

The poem begins with the assertion that the speaker's father loved them, yet it immediately introduces a sense of conflict by stating that the father gave away all he possessed to other siblings. This juxtaposition effectively conveys the speaker's mixed feelings about their father's love and the perceived favoritism towards the other siblings.

Throughout the poem, the speaker reflects on the lifelong memory their father left behind, with the lines "he comes to me daily / six decades since / still kisses me." This image is both tender and haunting, underscoring the lasting impact of the father's presence in the speaker's life.

The poem takes an interesting turn when the speaker describes a dream in which their father offers reassurance and a promise of future prosperity: "Don't worry...WAIT AND SEE...ENJOY LIFE... / ONE DAY IT WILL RAIN GOLD FOR THEE." This moment adds depth to the poem, as it suggests a potential reconciliation or understanding between the speaker and their father.

The poem concludes with the speaker acknowledging the love and support of their present family, reinforcing the idea that they are not solely defined by their relationship with their father. This ending offers a sense of resolution and hope for the speaker, despite the lingering complexities of their feelings towards their father.

One area for improvement might be to refine the poem's structure and language. While the conversational tone is engaging, some of the phrasing and line breaks could be reworked to enhance the poem's flow and readability. Additionally, the poem's repetition of certain lines could be revised to create a stronger impact and further develop the themes explored in the piece.

In conclusion, "My Dad Loved Me" is a heartfelt and thought-provoking poem that delves into the complexities of a father-child relationship and the influence of family dynamics. The poem's conversational tone and intimate atmosphere effectively convey the speaker's emotions and experiences, while the exploration of themes such as love, memory, and hope adds depth and nuance to the piece. By refining the poem's structure and language, the overall impact and readability of the poem can be further enhanced.

you are just dreaming of what you would have liked to have had, maybe your father was smarter than you think. Maybe he left your siblings all of his estate, because he knew that they would never be able to take care of themselves, whereas he knew that you would have enough brains to do for yourself. I agree, don't make your father shout, it ruins the feel of dreaming.
Otherwise, a really good piece. ~ Geez.
.

I think this is one of your best of late. Nice job! ~ Geez.
.