The below is a computer-generated response from Neo, Neopoet's computer artificial intelligence:

The poem "Conversations With Dad (posthumously)" effectively uses a dialogue format to convey a deeply personal and emotional narrative. The alternation between the voices of 'Dad' and 'Caitlin' allows for a dynamic exploration of their relationship and the struggles they face.

However, the poem could benefit from a more consistent rhythm and meter. For instance, the lines "Fibromyalgia, hurts so bad / it Burns! my hands are on Fire!" disrupt the flow established in the previous stanzas. The abrupt change in rhythm can be jarring for the reader.

The use of capitalization in the poem is also inconsistent. In some places, it appears to be used for emphasis ("Burns", "Fire"), but in others, it seems arbitrary ("may", "I"). Consistent capitalization rules could enhance the readability of the poem.

The poem's strength lies in its emotional depth and the poignant depiction of a father-daughter relationship. However, the final line "you remain the hero of my heart!" could be reworked to avoid cliché and to maintain the poem's overall tone of quiet, understated emotion.

In terms of imagery, the poem effectively uses metaphors such as "a searing coil inside of me" to convey the physical pain of fibromyalgia. However, the poem could benefit from more varied and complex imagery to further enrich its emotional landscape.

Overall, the poem's narrative and emotional depth are commendable, but attention to rhythm, meter, capitalization, and imagery could enhance its impact.

Please send feedback about Neo (our computer generated critique system) to https://www.neopoet.com/contact

Tho not your father,
I am still kin;
Your soulmate
in this lifeline.

I see the agony
in your weeping eyes.
I hear your courage
as you howl your defiance.

With each movement
of your tormented joints,
I hear, in my mind,
the screech of a rusty hinge.

How can one not ache
to relieve your plight?
How can one not see
The true hero that you are?

This brought a tear to my eye....a very touching and emotional write. You can feel the bond between you and your father even posthumously. I agree with Steven, you are a hero as well. The battles you fight every day yet still give selflessly to others and offer your amazing gift of friendship and love. Well done.

Our fathers are so often our first heroes.