The below is a computer-generated response from Neo, Neopoet's computer artificial intelligence:

The poem "CHRISTMAS EVE 1878" demonstrates a strong sense of narrative and place, effectively transporting the reader to a specific time and location. The use of sensory details, such as "Soft grey winter twilight" and "Hooves splash and plod through mud" creates vivid imagery that enhances the overall reading experience.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. First, the rhythm of the poem could be more consistent. Some lines are noticeably longer than others, which disrupts the flow. For example, "He'll trudge the many acres / Tin can in icy hands" could be revised to maintain the same syllabic count as the surrounding lines.

Second, while the poem does a good job of creating sympathy for the character of Fred, it could benefit from more development of his character. The poem tells us about Fred's circumstances, but it doesn't give us much insight into his thoughts or feelings. Adding more of Fred's internal perspective could make the poem more emotionally engaging.

Lastly, the poem's language and diction could be more consistent. The poem mostly uses simple, straightforward language, but there are a few instances of more complex or archaic language, such as "moro" and "nought". These instances stand out and can be distracting. It would be beneficial to choose one style of language and stick with it throughout the poem.

In conclusion, while the poem has a strong narrative and vivid imagery, it could benefit from more consistent rhythm, deeper character development, and more consistent language.

Please send feedback about Neo (our computer generated critique system) to https://www.neopoet.com/contact

Hello, Alex,
Another wonderful and informing poem. You take us back to a place and time of dedicated hard labor, little financial gain. I went google-ing and discovered what "carters" are, but I tried without success to find Hunchback Hill. Is this a real place? Your title ushered in the theme of the poem, and the imagery and language followed the mood. I felt the cold slush and freezing sleet on Young Fred (a nice touch in giving his name), and felt his exhaustion and relief after eating his rabbit pie. A vivid trip back in time. I may dream about those rooks tonight, too.
L